11
May
This means your paper is undergoing preliminary. In case of Elseveir journal the status date changes and status changes to under editor evaluation when the 3 reviewer comments are added into the system or whatever be the minimum number of.
The status Under Editor Evaluation implies that the peer review process is now complete and the Associate Editor AE has received the peer review report.
Under editor evaluation after under review elsevier. The status has now changed from Under review to Under editor evaluation with only three days in under review. What does it mean. What does it mean.
The status initially changed from Submitted to journal to With editor within a day and from With editor to Under review. You can get some extra insight if you know how long the paper was in each stage. If the paper was under review for a long time depending on how long it typically takes to review a paper in your field and then went to under editor evaluation for a few weeks before reverting back to under review that would be indirect evidence for this guess.
The status under editor evaluation indicates that the paper is now with the Associate Editor AE who will evaluate it based on the reviews and decide whether the paper should be accepted rejected or revised. What does it mean when a paper status is changed from Under Review to Under Editors evaluation and then again changed to Under Review at Elsevier. Under Review means that the reviewers are working on the manuscript and have not returned their review report and judgment about the manuscript to the editor-in-chief EiC of the journal.
The status Under editor evaluation indicates that the peer review for your paper is now complete and it is currently with the Associate Editor AE who will evaluate it based on the reviews and decide whether the paper should be accepted rejected or sent back for revisions. The status Under Editor Evaluation implies that the peer review process is now complete and the Associate Editor AE has received the peer review report. Based on the report the AE can now make a recommendation to the Editor-in-Chief EiC of the journal on whether to accept reject or send the manuscript back for revision.
Note however that the AE can only make a. It implies that the reviews for your paper have come in and the editor can now make a decision on your paper. If the status changes back to under review the editor is probably not satisfied with the reviews heshe has received and has sent your manuscript for an additional review.
This can happen if the reviewers have conflicting views or if one or more of the reviews are weak or. For Under editor evaluation means. Minimum number of reviewer comments are added to the system.
The Under Editor Evaluation status is not mentioned in the Elsevier site. However there are minor variations in the workflows of different Elsevier journals. Perhaps the journal you have submitted to uses this status while others dont.
This status indicates that the Editor is evaluating your manuscript based on the peer reviewer comments but has not yet come to a decision. If the editor is satisfied with the. In case of Elseveir journal the status date changes and status changes to under editor evaluation when the 3 reviewer comments are added into the system or whatever be the minimum number of.
Under consideration in some journals like nature is equivalent to with the editor in other journals such as Elsevier and Springer publications. This means your paper is undergoing preliminary. Under editor evaluation mean that one of the reviewer replly to the editor and said that he cant evaluet the paper the editor searche for a new reviewer.
Answered 9 months ago Author has 195 answers and 2188K answer views Under Editor Evaluation mean editor has not reviewed tvnot decided to go ahead with the paper and assigned peer reviewed. Decision in Process means peer review completed and recommendations received but editor has not taken decision. Hope this is helpful.
Under the section Speed click Review Speed to see the average number of weeks it takes for a manuscript to reach first and final decision. If you are waiting considerably longer to receive a decision from the Editor than the average review speed indicates you can contact the Editor. To contact the Editor you must be the Corresponding Author.
Peter Thrower PhD is Editor-in-Chief of Carbon the international journal of the American Carbon Society and Professor Emeritus of Material Sciences and Engineering at Penn State University. The article contains elements that are suspected to be plagiarized or it is currently under review at another journal. Republishing articles or parts of articles submitting to one or more journals at the.
Elsevier Journalへ論文投稿を行いました約2週間のunder review期間を経過した後にUnder Editor EvaluationというstatusになりましたUnder Editor Evaluationはどういう状態でしょうかrejectの可能性があるという意味なのでしょうかまたDecision in Processとはどう違うのでしょうか教えてください. 논문 상태가 Under review 후 Under editor evaluation으로 바뀌었다면 논문의 피어 리뷰가 종료되었고 에디터가 결정을 내리기 위해 수집한 리뷰와 논문을 검토하고 있다는 의미입니다. 한 달 넘게 같은 상태라면 에디터에게 메일로 논문 상태가 언제쯤 바뀔지 또는 논문에 대한 결정이 언제쯤 완료될지 문의해보셔도 좋을 듯합니다.
참고할 만 한 글. 最近很多人在投Elesvier期刊的时候遇到遇到Under Editor Evaluation这种状态网上有很多种说法这种状态通常是两种情况1经过很短时间的Under Review后直接变成Under Editor Evaluation状态然后很短时间就是Decision in Process状态这种情况基本上就是Reject文章没送审而编辑直接给意见了如Journal of Power Sources2在经过很长时间的Under Review状态之后不经过Required Review.