22
May
We appreciate your insightful suggestions. Eg John Smith MD or Carolyn Daniels MPH Title eg Editor-in-Chief Managing Editor Co-Editors-in-Chief Journal Name Journal Address.
Getting and responding to reader feedback are all part of the joys of the academic publishing experience.
Rebuttal letter example journal. Rebuttal Letter Dear Editor. To the journals rule. Thank you for noting this.
As you suggested we corrected the references according to the journals rule. 2 The present study is very important and interesting but authors should revise to publish. Authors should write abbreviations to first place in abstract.
We appreciate your insightful suggestions. Rebuttal letter Manuscript ID. FTO genotype and weight loss.
A systematic review and meta-analysis of 9563 individual participant data from eight randomized controlled trials Thank you for the opportunity to address the comments from the Reviewers and the Committee members. The authors hope that the Reviewers and Editors will be satisfied with the further. Although not a requirement a cover letter has set the tone for this academic exchange.
First the author appropriately thanks the reviewers for their time and comments. Next the author gives a high-level response to what seems to be the main concerns of the paper. Finally the author has signed the rebuttal on behalf of his co-authors.
I am writing this rebuttal letter in response to the performance evaluation you issued me on the 1st of this month. I am grateful and appreciative of the performance you did in the past year. However I have some reservations to make.
ANNOTATED TEMPLATEJournal Submissions Rebuttal Letter Journal Editors First and Last Name Graduate Degree if any TIP. Its customary to include any graduate degrees in the addressees name. Eg John Smith MD or Carolyn Daniels MPH Title eg Editor-in-Chief Managing Editor Co-Editors-in-Chief Journal Name Journal Address.
10 Effective Rebuttal Letter Samples Examples Writing Guidelines A rebuttal letter is a formally written communique that expresses the ideas arguments and the terms of a rebuttal. You will need this kind of letter to counter any unfounded allegations request for a refund after the purchase of fake items and respond to any false allegations in a court proceeding among others. A rebuttal letter offers authors an opportunity to address reviewers concerns directly defend aspects of work and eliminate contextual misunderstandings.
This stepwise breakdown of writing a rebuttal letter aims to assist authors during the revision. An academic rebuttal letter can be a great chance to convince referees and editors that your paper is good and should be published in that journal. Often it is your last opportunity to emphasize the quality of your work during the peer review process.
So before writing a rebuttal letter you should take time to examine the reviewer comments very carefully and determine the nature of the revisions. Resubmitting a Paper after Necessary Revisions Have Been Made. Dr Sandra Jones Department of Social Sciences University of the Pacific Coast PO.
Box 101 Salmon Cove British Columbia V2K 3L4 Canada 609 741-8955 sandrajonesunivpaccoastca. Mr Reginald Smith Editor Journal of Changing Weather PO. Box 707 River Rapids Oregon 76545 USA.
The rebuttal letter provided supporting evidence to make it clear that the reviewer had not reviewed the revised manuscript thoroughly. Within a few days the editor replied stating that the paper would be discussed by the editorial board and sent out for a. Writing a rebuttal letter for an academic journal.
By Kyle Crocco Writing Peer. Thursday July 21 2016 335 PM. Getting and responding to reader feedback are all part of the joys of the academic publishing experience.
But how do you respond to reader feedback to show how you have improved your manuscript or that you umm politely disagree. The journal may be interested in your study but will not commit itself until the editors and reviewers see the added data or corrections. This type of rejection letter will usually say that should you choose to resubmit the manuscript would need to be received within a rea-sonable period of time usually 23 months to be con-sidered as a revision.
A template for writing rebuttal letters to reviews for journal submissions.